Pink Fire Pointer Water Pelican Proof
Showing posts with label Internet. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Internet. Show all posts

Age of conspiracies


This picture has been buzzing round the internet immediately after the Boston bombings. Who is this man?

The Boston bombings are compelling firstly because they are awful to contemplate but secondly because they are, as of yet, motiveless (if it was Al-Qaeda we would have been told straight away). The President initially did not even call the bombings and act of terrorism, then he did, but he still upset some people.

For the time being there is room for myth-making and pareidolia. What was that man doing on the roof? What would anyone do on a roof?

There are immediate psychological reasons for embracing conspiracy theories, the solidarity of the initiated, perverse reassurance about human agency and so on.  There are political reasons why one may promote a conspiracy theory, or conspiracism in general. Fear and projection are key stimulating factors for right wing populist movements, the tributaries of fascism.

The unacceptable attributes of the self, in this case a political body, for example a nation or a race, are projected on the enemy, who is always more powerful, cunning and prolific. Triumph over the enemy requires urgent action, great passion is mobilised, and it becomes a transforming force. It helps also when you find attributes of the enemy within the political body, these people become ‘traitors’ and can be dealt with peremptorily (btw – is anyone else spotting a similarity between this and the SWP CC’s epistemology of internal debate? – a leap I appreciate, but word has it Alex Callinicos turned up at a CC meeting with a copy of the infamous Facebook conversation and started ranting about conspiracies).

There is a short Marxist rider to this, we live in the age of public life, where all the formal decisions about society are taken in the open, yet society seems to career down strange, unwarranted paths beyond any apparent human control. Noam Chomsky contrasts conspiracy theories to institutional analysis. Conspiracies fill the gap left by the absence of the theory of class rule, the nature of the state. Perhaps this means they are part of the operation of bourgeois hegemony? In which case more consideration is necessary.

IS Network - new website

And it looks pretty good. the founding meeting was yesterday. Somewhere between 50-100 people were there. Things went very well in my opinion. This an the Left Unity initiative (which the ISN has decided to support) are two reasons to be cheerful.

The dark side...


Alex Callinicos complaining on Facebook that he had his invitation to participate in the Historical Materialism conference in Delhi withdrawn at short notice by email, rounded off by saying: 

"This is to say nothing of the personal inconvenience and expense you are exposing me to by withdrawing your invitation a week after you had circulated a programme that included me as chairing one session and speaking at another, and barely a week before I was due to fly to India. This is quite unacceptable in what is meant to be an academic conference, and it is also not how socialists should behave towards one another." 

However one of the Facebook Four quite rightly pointed out: 

"YOU EXPELLED ME BY EMAIL". 

For someone who is a professor - Alex Callinicos is really quite dumb, and it shows where his priorities lie. What really gets his goat is the prospect looming of no more academic conferences.

Get on t'internet...


“Comrades need to stop complaining on the internet and bring their concerns to branch meetings”. I paraphrase, but variations on this canard are repeated quite often, sometimes with an addendum along the lines of, “we need to engage with the real world”.

We do need to engage with the real world but moral injunctions about branch meetings are just the opposite of such engagement. Revolutionary socialists advocate direct discussion and open voting against closed meetings and secret ballots, but this fine, hard won principle is not being applied intelligently.

Any medium is by definition is exclusive. You’re either online or not. You can either attend a meeting or you can’t. There are plenty of reasons why someone might not be able to make regular meetings on a Wednesday or Thursday night, too many to list. It certainly doesn’t make you lazy or devious or your opinions invalid. It can equally be said that electronic communication provides an invaluable resource for people not able to meet face to face. In fact it allows a far greater pooling of experience and information than a geographical branch.

But there’s more to it than this. There is an unacknowledged bias that has been hardened by the misapplication of the idea of direct democracy. Why does a branch meeting count as the real world (when quite often it’s a group of ardent left-wingers agreeing with each other then arranging a paper sale) when online discussion does not?

It is, in part, a residual prejudice of 20thCentury thought. Using McLuhanite terms, under print media the written word is dissociated and cool, whereas the spoken word is involved and hot. The written word had elevated status because it was recorded, for all time.

Thanks to electronic media the written word can unfold as fast as spoken conversation. There is no going back to the old ways of thinking. The internet not only has an idiom of its own (idiom being a sure sign of intense involvement not cool dissociation) but is affecting language and communication in general.

The party must come to understand electronic media and incorporate them as part of a democratic mix, including print media and public meetings, or it will become irrelevant, and all for the sake of principles transformed into shibboleths. To put it another way, if you don’t like what people are saying online don’t hide away in your branch meetings, get out into the real world, get online.

The internet told me to do it

During the Cold War every political event, even the most ephemeral, was granted some deeper, sinister meaning; it was all down to the International Communist Conspiracy. These neo-liberal days the powers that be try to render all events, even grand ones such as revolutions, as meaningless. What sparked the London riots? Not arrogant, corrupt policing. Not general political atrophy. Not low wages and unemployment, a lack of opportunity and a declining future. No.



It was social media, the mysterious cyber-Loki fanning enigmatic conflagrations from here to Cairo. Get ready for the 2012 bill banning the internet.

In praise of tired, old routines

Let's get to the point, I'm talking about the making and selling of newspapers. Two things must be said, I think.

(1) Nobody, but nobody, no meaningful actor on the British left has put out a serious document/thesis/whatever arguing that newspapers are all and the internet is nothing and it shall be that way forever, amen. For one thing, if you could find such a document, right now, it would be, yup, on the internet.

No one hypes newspapers. People do hype the internet. At the basic mainstream level people hype the internet as a way of denying agency. The Arab people did not make the revolution, Facebook did. It's cobblers.

No one should pretend there's some absolutist orthodoxy about paper sales they're bravely railing against. There isn't.

(2) The distributing printed word is time consuming, energy consuming and expensive. When people suggest "you're just interested in selling papers" I tend to reply, "of course I'm not. I'd rather someone else did this for me, but that's not going to happen". What can having a printed paper do for you? I am in a London branch of the SWP, there are two branches in my borough. In our branch we have one street sale, usually on a Saturday, two regular workplace sales and a few more irregular ones. In the course of organising these sales the branch brings a dozen to two dozen people into activity. The basic propagandism of a street sale is not everything, but it should not be underestimated. Amongst other things, the day-to-day opportunities for making Bolshevism, even in unionised workplaces, are slim. The sale is a chance to put your ideas to some kind of a test.

In the course of regular, hum-drum activity, like meetings and sales, the branch can accurately estimate who can be counted on, who can do what and to what likely effect. I'd say there are 20-30 people regularly active in this branch during an average month, modest compared to our ultimate ambition but hey-ho... We can only know this because we ask people to complete regular, horrible, abstract drudgery, actual physical tasks.

The internet can't do this.

Discussion on Marshall McLuhan

Listen here. Below is a neat summary of the significance of media forms. It is, of course, lacking the class dimension of understanding media. Our media, our way of experiencing the world, is owned by someone else. That ownership affects what is produced, how it is produced and for what end. None the less it is an excellent jumping off point for discussions about the clash of base and superstructure, media, society and change.

The medium, or process of our time – electric technology – is reshaping and restructuring patterns of social interdependence and every aspect of our personal life. It is forcing us to reconsider and re-evaluate practically every thought, every action, and every institution formerly taken for granted. Everything is changing – you, your family, your neighbourhood, your education, your job, your government, your relation to "the others." And they're changing dramatically.

Societies have always been shaped more by the nature of the media by which men communicate than by the content of the communication. The alphabet, for instance, is a technology that is absorbed by the very young child in a completely unconscious manner, by osmosis so to speak. Words and the meaning of words predispose the child to think and act automatically in certain ways. The alphabet and print technology fostered and encouraged a fragmenting process, a process of specialism and of detachment. Electric technology fosters and encourages unification and involvement. It is impossible to understand social and cultural changes without a knowledge of the workings of media.

The older training of observation has become quite irrelevant in this new time, because it is based on psychological responses and concepts conditioned by the former technology – mechanization.

Innumerable confusions and a profound feeling of despair invariably emerge in periods of great technological and cultural transitions. Our "Age of Anxiety" is, in great part, the result of trying to do today's job with yesterday's tools – with yesterday's concepts.

Youth instinctively understands the present environment – the electric drama. It lives mythically and in depth. This is the reason for the great alienation between generations. Wars, revolutions, civil uprisings are interfaces within the new environments created by electric informational media.

Marshall McLuhan, 'The Medium is the Massage: An Inventory of Effects' (1967).